Flood Warning expires at 10:10 AM on 8/22, issued at 12:02 AM Amsterdam, NY | Auriesville, NY | Canajoharie, NY | Esperance, NY

Deliberations begin for Copeland trial

Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large
Share
Updated: 4/23 10:24 am
TROY, N.Y. – A Rensselaer County Jury will begin deliberating the fate of a Troy woman who is accused of killing her father.

Closing arguments wrapped up on Tuesday in the Trinity Copeland trial, but not before Copeland took the stand in her own defense. She faces second degree murder charges as the jury deliberates on Wednesday.  

Copeland, 18, testified that she shot her father, Harlan, in 2012 out of fear for her own life. He was found with one gunshot wound to the head. A firearm, believed to be the weapon involved, was recovered at scene.

However, prosecutors argue that Copeland killed her father in cold blood; after he found out she had stolen his debit card. Prosecution also states that the woman purchased $150 worth of items on the debit card.Authorities say the bank had just alerted Harlan when they had their altercation.

The defense did not deny that Copeland, then 17-years old, pulled the trigger, but they continue to say that it was out of self-defense. Copeland’s attorney said the evidence will show Harlan had a drinking problem and that he was drunk that morning and Trinity was in danger. She said she confessed to her father about taking his debit card. In response, she said her father went into his room and got a gun. She claims he was drunk at the time of the confrontation and he pointed the gun to her head. On the stand, she said her father was an alcoholic.

Copeland recalled that her father said he was going to kill her then himself because he wasn't going to go to prison. She told the jury on Tuesday that she tried pleading with her dad, which is when he allegedly suggested Trinity kill him or he would kill them both.

The prosecution, however, told th
jury that Copeland initially told a neighbor and police that someone broke into the apartment and shot her father. They say Copeland showed no emotion and later changed her story. The prosecution also said Trinity laughed during the interview with detectives, and that she called her father a jerk to detectives just four hours after shooting.

Copeland did not deny the jerk references. On the stand, she said she shot her father because she feared for her own life and felt she had no choice. She added that she wasn't thinking clearly, she was thinking she was going to die. She said she knew her father was going to kill her.


And during cross-examination, prosecutors went through different options Trinity could have taken instead of killing her father, like trying to escape when she had the chance, or call 911, or even shoot her father somewhere other than his head. Trinity says she didn't think of that at the time.

The defense told the jury that Copeland had no choice, and reminded them that there are times when someone may need to use force to protect themselves.

Copeland spent about 10 months behind bars after she admitted to the shooting, but she was released from the Rensselaer County Jail in May 2013, when the original murder indictment against her was dropped. Rensselaer County District Attorney Richard McNally said the court found prosecutors failed to properly instruct grand jury.

In September of 2013 she was re-arraigned on charges of second-degree Murder and first-degree Manslaughter, to which she plead not guilty.
Share
0 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of FOX23 News.

No comments yet!
Current Conditions
66°
High: 76° | Low: 65°
Light Rain

Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.