Lake Effect Snow Warning expires at 10:00 AM on 11/21, issued at 8:26 AM Blue Mountain Lake, NY | Caroga Lake, NY | Hoffmeister, NY | Indian Lake, NY

Two dogs to be put down after deadly attack on smaller dog

Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large
Updated: 8/27 5:45 pm

SCHENECTADY, N.Y. – A judge has ordered two Schenectady dogs to be euthanized after they attacked a smaller terrier in June.

Judge Steven Swinton ruled that both dogs involved in the attack will be put down. 

"We don't kill child molesters and murders in this state, but we kill dogs, it doesn't really make sense to me," said Lindsey McKearn.

While in court, owner Sean McKearn pleaded guilty to his misdemeanor charge for harboring a dangerous dog. McKearn must pay a $2,000 restitution and serve 75 hours of community service. The judge also ruled that the two dogs must be put down and McKearn is not allowed to own a dog for the next year. 

"Sick, I feel awful for both parties,” said McKearn.

Judge Swinton said that while McKearn was not the worst person that he has seen in his court room, he is was described to be the most childish.

McKearn and his family did not want to hear the verdict reached on Wednesday, after fighting for nearly two months.

"We're heartbroken as a family, we're heartbroken for the other family, and we're heartbroken for our dogs that we loved so much,” said Kevin McKearn, Sean McKearn's father.

On August 13, a Schenectady judge ruled that one of the dogs, named Victor, must be put down. The second dog, Tyson, had to remain in the city kennel pending further decision by the judge.

On June 30, McKearn's dogs jumped out of a window at their home and went after a smaller dog, which was being walked by its owner. The smaller dog died a few days later. Police have said that this wasn't the first time the dogs had been involved in attacks on other animals, but the owners said they got loose because of human error and not aggression.

While in court, the owners of Templeton, the small dog, stood up in court for the first time, calling the terrier a poster dog against animal attacks. 

"I hope that Mr. McKearn understands why he got the sentence, and I think that going forward, other dog owners will hopefully take this under advisement to handle their dogs better," said Rebecca Cigal, Templeton's owner.

The two parties seem to agree they are just happy to have the whole ordeal over with after arguments for two months.

"It's sad that three dogs have to be put down in this case,” said McKearn.

Victor and Tyson are currently being held at the city kennel, an exact time and date to put them down has not been set. The city attorney says it will likely happen this week, and the family says they wish they can be present when it does.  

2 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of FOX23 News.

dawn james - 9/6/2014 5:37 PM
0 Votes
no mention of breed but lemme guess... jumps out of window to attack a dog walking down the street. dogs have a history of attacking other animals. owners launch a defense of the dogs savagery by claiming HUMAN ERROR (ie their own stupidity and incompetence) and not innate dog aggression. dangerous dog owner compares his vicious dogs to human child molesters. i could be totally wrong but this smells like a chiwawa mauling. and by chiwawa, i mean PIT BULLDOG.

animal house - 8/29/2014 9:07 PM
0 Votes
Really human error not aggression what the hell do u call what those evil ugly things did to poor templeton being friendly? I wish I could be there to smile at those beasts as they get their death injection!! What an awesome judge not having any nonsense like some other judges do when it comes to this evil breed he gets my vote also tedisco n riggi for dangerous dogs postings the mayor does not tbough !! Too bad sean mckearn had only to pay two grand was hoping for fifteen grand for sweet templeton !! Hopefully in near future a ban on these demon dogs will be in place !! Irresponsible owners own them cause responsible owners have too much common sense n wouldn't own these things!
Current Conditions
High: 40° | Low: 22°
Light Snow

Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.